Search The Line of Best Fit
Search The Line of Best Fit

"Are You My Mother?"

Kathryn Calder – Are You My Mother?
09 September 2011, 15:09 Written by David Newbury
Email

The Canadian music scene has to be the most exciting outside of Scandinavia, and just as varied. Take a look at this year’s Polaris prize; The Weeknd, Galaxie, Timbre Timbre and the entire list have all released exciting, innovative and musically different albums which will still be played when the next nominees are revealed. It puts Britain’s radio-friendly-unit-shifter Mercury list to shame. Basically, Canadians are cool, Scandinavians are cool, we suck.

It wasn’t always this way. Go back 15, even ten years, and people would joke: “Name five Canadian musicians.”

“No problem. Here we go, Bryan Adams, Celine Dion, Neil Young…. Rush….erm.… Alanis Morissette?”

Ask for a sixth and even grown musos would weep, promising to embrace new music technology like the Mini Disk providing no one learnt of their musical impotence. South Parks takes on Canada was seen as truthful.

As a reaction to Terrance and Phillip, Canada’s MOR pit was bridged over a decade ago when within six months The New Pornographers released their debut album, Mass Romantic and another band called Something-or-another 41 shat onto MTV2- the latter deserving no place in history, so let us never talk of them again. With Mass Romantic there was suddenly a Cud-esque, alternative indie-pop record made by an alt-underground supergroup. But this was Canada, what alt-underground? Well one member was Destroyer’s Dan Bejar, and another was a country-noir siren named Neko Case.

Although an American, Case gave The New Pornographers a distinctive edge and arguable set the band up as unofficial godparents to Canada’s indie scene. However, she was more at home in a poppy country sound with a voice which is a bit to crisp for the indie scene. So in 2006, with a swelling solo career, and a lifetime ban from the Grand Ole Opry, Case handed her main vocal duties over to, Porno’s guitarist, Carl Newman’s niece, Kathryn Calder.

Calder is a far indier vocalist than Case, honed with lo fi indie-poppers Immaculate Machine, and has given The New Pornographers a twee folk element which they previously missed. Are You My Mother? is Calder’s first solo album and sees her frame this twee orientation in her own brand of gentle fuzzy dream indie, but this is no saccharine affair. Each track’s vocal on Are You My Mother? is delicate with a dark sadness which provides a substance to the sometimes naïve melodies. Grief underlines the album, Calder was caring for her dying mother during its recording, and the emotion is intensely laid bare on opener ‘Slip Away’. Over the emptiest of piano and a building rim tap she sings “I’m holding onto something lost, I should just let go an move along / When I’m fast asleep it flutters by my pond, when I wake up it’s gone / Slip Away”. They are heartfelt simple lyrics but by no means maudlin, for suddenly the song breaks into a New Pornographers style hooky chorus which celebrates this grief rather than being consumed by it.

The Porno’s influence can further be felt on ‘A Long Day Past its Prime’ with its sprightly stomp and distorted indie rock. The excellent ‘Castor and Pollox’ also veers toward climactic indie-pop yet subtly introduces her hazy panderings through a vocal reminiscent of twee lo fi-ers, It’s Jo and Danny. However, it’s Calder’s charm and delicate poetic warmth which dominates the songs, whether that be with rousing La La Las on ‘Dry The River ‘ or the camp site romp of ‘If You Only Knew’. There are of course moments of melancholia with the beautifully sparse and Case featuring ‘Arrows’ and ‘So Easily’, which makes Warpaint’s ‘Billie Holiday’ sound like the Billie Joe Armstrong, but ‘Are You My Mother?’ is essentially an upbeat album. Especially with the latino-cowboy ‘Follow Me Into The Hills.’

With only ten tracks at 36 minutes Are You My Mother is cruelly short as it’s such a welcoming and easy album, so needs to be played over again. Far from being filled with pining ballads and twee whimsy, as the album first suggests, it sincerely celebrates life with Calder encapsulating everything she enjoys and remembers. However, this can be it’s only, minor, downfall, it’s a bit too erratic; ballad, rousing, jolly, tearful, grooving, melancholic, it meanders around all emotions rather than being focused. But this is how people are, they have different sides and they are not always predictable. Are You My Mother? is Calder as a person and we can feel her beautiful jollity in a gloriously refined record, which is sure to be a hidden gem, so don’t let it pass you by.

Share article
Email

Get the Best Fit take on the week in music direct to your inbox every Friday

Read next