Peggy Sue: “I don’t think you ever get to a point when you’re writing and you think you’ve reached your best”

Photo Credit: Eleonora Collini/ Line of Best F

The music of Peggy Sue doesn’t really fall into any genre. Formerly known as Peggy Sue And The Pirates, Rosa ‘Rex’ Slade and Katy ‘Klaw’ Young started playing together in 2005 and were later joined by drummer Olly Joyce. Calling themselves a post-folk band and writing songs based around delicate layers of guitars and brooding vocals, the London trio has sublimely combined the soul tradition of country-blues with the slacker vibes of indie rock. Following Fossils and Other Phantoms (2010) and Acrobats (2011), their third full-length Choir of Echoes is now out on Wichita Records in the UK and Yep Roc in the States. 

It’s their album release show in the beautiful St Old Pancras Church (which couldn’t be a better venue for their ethereal, somehow spiritual music) and Rosa, Katy, Olly and touring bassist Ben Rubinstein are excited. After taking some portrait photos, Rosa and I try and look for a quiet spot to chat, and after first sitting on the spiral stairs that lead to the organ room, we then end up on a bench in the church’s front yard.

Rosa tells me that she’s pretty proud of how Choir of Echoes turned out. “We recorded it in South Wales at Rockfield Studios which is most famous for “Bohemian Rhapsody”, and when we arrived the Pixies had just left which is kinda cool.” Jimmy Robertson produced the record and longtime collaborator John Askew mixed it. “For this album we had more time”, Rosa explains. “We recorded there for about a month. That was actually the first time that we’d written in just one place. We had a vision of what it was going to sound like and what the idea behind it was going to be. We wanted to do a more relaxed record which was more expansive sonically. It was quite a fulfilling album to make.”

As the title suggests, the new record is about voices, “not so much about singing which is obviously such an important part of what Peggy Sue’s sound is”, Rosa specifies, “ but it’s more about finding your voice and singing again, like doing playful harmonies and things like that, like the idea of traditional backing singing, hence the plural ‘voices’.” She then continues: ” but it’s also about finding your voices, more in terms of personal life. And the power of words or the construction of a word, which is specific to a language. We talked a lot about what a word can do, how you can say something and how that can be miscommunicated, and how you can understand something differently from what a person is trying to say. That’s to me the idea of voices being very powerful.”

I ask her to elaborate the album’s title and she points out that it comes from the myth of Echo, “who was a nymph that managed to trick people with her words, so as result she was cursed so that she could only repeat what someone had just said. And negatively, the fact that someone can do so much but then you can take it away from them is such a powerful urge. That’s what Choir of Echoes is about.”

One of the things that I have always liked about Peggy Sue is that they keep switching instruments on stage. So I am curious about how their writing process works and if they end up playing the instrumental parts they wrote. “To be honest you are not going to like this…as at the moment there is less switching!”, Rosa jokes. “Having said that, we have always found it very fun to pick up a new instrument and learn how to play new weird chord structures and things that don’t really exist. That stimulates your creativity and you write things you haven’t written previously. We got lots of new songs out of new instruments as we didn’t know how to play them.” It’s mainly her and Katy that come up with melodies, then the band gets together and writes around that. “Sometimes a song can come out of a jam”, she carries on, “and we just put lyrics on it which is the difficult part as both Katy and I write very personal lyrics, so writing collaboratively can be difficult.”