
Ahead of an appearance at Primavera Pro this week, writer and critic Liz Pelly reveals the music that's marked the seasons of her life.
With so much of her work revolving around how and why we relate to music in the ways we do, the music Liz Pelly has chosen for her Nine Songs is, she says, a signifier of some core period or memory for her.
“Trying to figure out the beginning of this list, I have a really specific memory of the moment my life changed, and I became a person who is interested in music beyond the radio,” she explains. “It was fourth period, when my friend was talking to me about all of the bands she was into and was like, ‘You should go home and go on Napster and download music by this band called The Ataris.’ I’d never heard of any bands that weren’t on the radio before, and it was informative.”
Each of these songs similarly correspond to some vivid experience, and in taking us through them, she also takes us through her journey as a listener, person, and fan.
Pelly is the author of Mood Machine, a book that examines the role of Spotify and streaming platforms in the modern music economy. She's set to discuss the findings of her book this week at Primavera Pro. Pelly's also been published in The Baffler, The Guardian, Harper's, NPR, and Pioneer Works Broadcast, among outlets and is an adjunct instructor at NYU Tisch.
"The Greatest" by Cat Power
There are a few instances on this list where it’s really the album that’s etched into a specific season of life. So, what I chose for this one was the first song of that album. I can just hear the CD going on – like on the CD changer in my bedroom – as a high school senior.
There was this substitute teacher at the high school I went to who was really into music, and he was in a punk band but didn’t talk about it that much with students.
We were on a field trip once – it was like a high school orchestra field trip to the nursing home to play Christmas songs – and me and my sister were sitting in the front row of the bus trying to talk to the substitute teacher about music. He was like: “Oh! You guys are really into Taking Back Sunday. You should listen to Björk and Cat Power.”
He was just trying to get us into better music. Anyway, that’s how I got into Cat Power. I love “The Greatest” and that record. I just have it fully associated with walking around the suburban area I’m from in high school and being ready for the next part of my life to start.
"Blowin’ in the Wind" by Bob Dylan
When I was a college freshman, I was completely obsessed with Bob Dylan. Thinking of myself as a Bob Dylan scholar, I took a class in freshman year of college called, like, “Bob Dylan’s Lyrics.” It was like in college when you take those 101 writing classes, but sometimes they have specific themes. This was a writing class, but the theme was about Bob Dylan’s lyrics.
Anyway, at that time, The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan was my favourite album. I played it front to back – it was one of the first vinyl records that I ever got. Again, this is the first song from that record, but it’s also a song I still love.
Another fun piece of trivia from that season of my life is that, for a brief window of time, my favourite party trick was being able to recite every single one of Bob Dylan’s studio albums – the name of each one – in chronological order. I used a browser-based memorisation game to teach myself that trick. He has a lot of albums, so it seemed really impressive at the time.
"Sister Saint" by Waxahatchee
On a personal level, I just have that first Waxahatchee tape that came out. This was the first release, before American Weekend. It was just a few songs, and I have it so associated with my first apartment that I ever lived in towards the end of college in Massachusetts. Specifically, it really reminds me of sitting on the floor packing to move out of my first apartment. The summer it came out, it was just on a loop.
Also, at that time, Katie had already been in a certain corner of the DIY music scene. So, she already was someone who was kind of a little bit of a legendary musician to some people, because her bands had these cult followings.
When “Sister Saint” and the record it was on dropped, like, I recently described it to someone as that scene’s Liz Phair’s Girly-Sound records. These are really early home recordings. You hear them and you’re just like “Wow, this is amazing.”
This song is also attached to this memory for me of going to Lady Fest in East Hampton that happened in 2011. I lived in Boston at the time, and some of my friends drove out to this iteration of Lady Fest, which is sort of a feminist punk festival with roots in post-Riot Grrrl traditions.
Not only did Katie play at that festival, but it was the first time I ever saw her play. It was so special, and those early Waxahatchee songs remind me of that time.
"Cynicism" by Nana Grizol
Nana Griznol are such an important band to me and have been for so long. There have been so many times over the past 15 years when I’ve considered getting a Nana Griznol tattoo, and I don’t have many tattoos. That’s honestly the main reason why I haven’t.
I love the whole Love It, Love It album, and if this was just a list of albums, I probably would have put that on. But, I was trying to think of my favourite Nana Grizol song, and the one I kept coming back to was “Cynicism.”
I feel like Nana Grizol are this band where everyone who’s a huge fan can tell you exactly who introduced them to the group. Even though this band has existed for a long time and has a pretty big DIY following, they’re also a word of mouth band to me too. I’m pretty sure that I learned about this band from someone I knew in college who was living in Athens, Georgia at the time.
I love folk punk, and knowing that some of the members of Nana Grizol have connections to Neutral Milk Hotel felt like discovering that musicians from scenes I didn’t necessarily associate with each other at all actually came from the same group. It felt so cool.
Also, I got to book a show for them in 2022 at a baseball diamond in Ridgewood. It was one of my favourite shows that I’ve ever booked.
"#1 Must Have" by Sleater-Kinney
I love Sleater-Kinney. They are one of my favourite bands and a big influence on me. This was also another instance where it was really hard to pick one song, but this song in particular I wanted to pick because in 2013, I launched a zine that became a really big part of my life. Actually, the only tattoo that I do have is its logo.
Anyway, in each issue, we did a mixtape that was part of the zine, and in the very first issue, I remember putting the song “#1 Must Have” on it. The lyric from the song, “culture is what we make”, is something that I come back to a lot because I think it’s so true.
In addition to Sleater-Kinney, I’m also a big fan of Corin Tucker’s band Heavens to Betsy. They’re a big influence on me musically, too. I play drums and write music, and I feel like a lot of times when I write songs, I’m thinking about Heavens to Betsy.
"Pink White House" by Priests
The first time I saw Priests was at a basement show in Boston in 2013. I almost picked their song “Personal Planes” because I have this vivid memory of watching them for the first time play that song at this show.
I’m so grateful that a band like Priest came along at a time when they did. When I think of Priests, I think of this record label that they ran called Sister Polygon Records. All the Sister Polygon bands were so good.
I saw Priests so many times over the years, and booked shows for them so many times over the years, and “Pink White House” is one of my favourite Priests songs. Also, the first article that I wrote for The Baffler about music streaming opened with a quote from this song.
"Art I Ficial" by X-Ray Spex
I’m someone for whom feminist punk music is sort of spiritual music in my life. X-Ray Spex are a band who in addition to being an amazing band that I think was totally ahead of its time, was also a band that has a huge influence on so many bands that have been so important to me.
I will also say, I learned so much about music from my sister. And X-Ray Spex is a band I learned about from her. The group was also influential on The Raincoats, and, eight years ago, my sister wrote a book about them. It’s one of my favourite books about music I’ve ever read. I know I’m biased, but it’s true!
With “Art I Ficial” specifically, I listened to this nonstop while I was working with my book. A few months ago, I made a list of songs that I listened to while I was working on my book, and this was the first song on my list. The lyrics about consumerism and culture are really ahead of their time. And there’s something about a song that that revolves around not just the word artificial but breaking it down into syllables and making you think about the word a little harder. I really appreciated that, especially when thinking about the AI hype cycle and trying to break it down.
Also, there was a documentary about Poly Styrene from X-Ray Spex and I literally just cried through the whole thing at the movie theatre I was watching it at, because I think she’s so important and deserves so much more from the music industry.
"When I’m Gone" by Phil Ochs
Phil Ochs came into my life a few years ago when I was writing a deep-dive, reported profile/essay on this woman named Sis Cunningham, who was a protest folk singer through the '40s, '50s, and '60s. One of the people who I interviewed for the piece and is quoted in the essay is Sonny Ochs , the sister of Phil Ochs, Phil Ochs having passed away many years ago as well.
So, while I was researching, I went to her house to look through her issues of Broadside – a zine that Sis Cunningham edited – and, naturally, I was also asking her some questions about her brother. When I asked her what her favourite song of Phil’s was, she said “When I’m Gone.”
I was kind of surprised at first, because I had listened to his music a little bit over the years but was more drawn to other kinds of protest songs. But after meeting his sister, I went home and listened to the song more closely and realised it was just one of the most beautiful songs I’d ever heard in my whole life.
It’s about really deeply believing in what’s important to you and living your values. The lyric that always stuck out to me from this song says: “I won't be laughing at the lies when I'm gone / And I can't question how, or when, or why when I'm gone.” As a journalist, I feel that lyric. I can’t question how or when or why when I’m gone, so I guess I’ll have to do it when I’m here.
I still listen to this song to this day. I really think of it as, you know, 'I only have finite time, and there’s only so much I have time to do, so I have to do the things that are really important to me.'
"Hard Times" by Gillian Welch
I have actually seen Gillian Welch play five times over the last year. I loved the Woodland record she put out last year and I wanted to catch that tour as many times as I could.
The song “Hard Times” is one that I had been familiar with, but it was really only over the past year of seeing her perform it live so many times that it hit me in a different way. I can’t claim exactly to know what the song is about from Gillian Welch’s perspective, but when I listen to it, I hear a song that seems to be about a version of automation impacting somebody’s ability to make a living, or technological progress impacting someone’s ability to make a living.
It has this lyric where she sings: “It’s a mean old world, heavy in need / And that big machine is just picking up speed.” That’s a lyric I think about not just in relation to music, but in relation to the society we live in.
And, I’ve been a fan of Gillian Welch for so long. There was a semester where I did a radio show that was folk and folk punk, and I remember I used to play Gillian Welch a bunch. I think I saw her play with Conor Oberst in high school or college. The first music festival that I ever went to was going to Newport Folk Festival to see Gillian Welch!
Primavera Pro runs from this week l at the Centre de Cultura Contemporània de Barcelona and the Parc del Fòrum.
Get the Best Fit take on the week in music direct to your inbox every Friday

Addison Rae
Addison

Loaded Honey
Love Made Trees

Pulp
More
