The PR attached to the 2009 remaster of Nirvana’s 1989 recording, Bleach, states, ‘This record is important’. Put into historical context, that certainly makes for a fair statement.
When Nirvana and producer Jack Endino took up residence in Seattle’s ‘Reciprocal Recording Studios’ at the end of 1988, shifting millions of records was probably not the primary thought of 21-year-old Kurt Cobain. Nonetheless, after ‘Nevermind’, ‘Bleach’ went on to achieve platinum sales, making it only one of two platinum selling records for label Sub Pop (the other is Flight Of The Conchords’ eponymous 2008 record). Not bad for an album that cost just £400 to make.
The two decades since the record’s release have seen Cobain’s rise to fame, his suicide and a derided resurrection in Guitar Hero 5. Licensing tracks to rhythm games brings with it great financial reward, so (without wishing to excuse the act) it’s easy to see why the choice was made. It also means that songs appearing in the game are remixed to allow each instrument to sound individually. Beyond this, songs are levelled using compression, to ensure there are no glaring differences in volume.
Similarly, the remastering of ‘classic’ albums is often intended to exploit a fan’s willingness to complete the collection of their favourite band. The Beatles, Rolling Stones and Def Leppard are amongst those who had remasters out in 2009.
Now joining that selection is Nirvana and, specifically, their debut album for Sub Pop Records, ‘Bleach’. Some of the questions for people that already own the original album ask are: Is it worth buying? How different does it sound? What have they done to it?
Remastered by the capable George Marino at Sterling Sound, let’s look at how the remaster sounds in comparison to the original.
I ripped two tracks (‘About A Girl’ and ‘Blew’) as WAV files and analysed them in Wavelab. Here’s the original of ‘About A Girl’.
About A Girl (Original)
As can be seen by simply looking at the wave, there is room for dynamic movement within the song, but there are a number of high peaks, particularly around the 2 minute mark (level gauge indicates that these peak at -0.02db just shy of the flat 0db). Any increase in volume to the overall file would mean result in those peaks exceeding 0db causing the file to clip (distort).
About A Girl (Remastered)
In comparison to the wave and level indicator of the remastered version, it’s immediately apparent just how much louder the overall recording is. Not only that, but the peaks are a lot more uniform which implies that the whole file has been compressed to give it more gain, and the top of those original peaks have been, to all intents and purposes, lopped off.
As soon as the drums come in on this laid-back, and naturally more dynamic number, the peak volume (as indicated by the meters) hits 0db and stays there throughout. The original, however, retains dynamic level changes so the volume rises and falls as the band play harder or softer respectively.
The equalisation of the track has also changed, with the remaster favouring less treble across the hi-hats, ride and tambourine – and generally making for a less exciting listen. Bass-light headphones (Sennheiser HD 280s) indicate the remaster contains more bass and greater lower mid-range frequencies giving the recordings more grind to bring them into line with present day rock records. A good stereo system will highlight the reduction in sound quality, but, on an average system, the most discernible change is increased volume.
Blew (Original)
Moving to full-on rock song, ‘Blew’, and more of the subtly nuanced bass-string noises can be heard on the intro to the remaster, but this is probably due to sheer volume than anything else. Again, the levels sit at 0db throughout with Kurt’s vocal sitting high in the mix as the presence of those splashy cymbals have been vastly reduced. There are less peaks in danger of clipping on this track, with only a couple at around 43 and 44s.
Blew (Remastered)
With the development of technology, the way we listen to music has changed drastically. As an MP3 amongst the collection on an 80GB iPod (or equivalent), the remastered tracks from ‘Bleach’ are going to stand up against the others in terms of volume, so you won’t have to turn them up that extra 3db. Whether that trade-off is worth the overall loss of quality is up to the listener and their individual preferences.
Of course, Bleach is a great album. Not only is it fun to listen to, it contains some of Nirvana’s best songs. In addition to this straight remaster, however, is a remastered recording of their oft bootlegged performance at the Pine Street Theatre (Portland, Oregon). With a remastered DVD and CD of their 1992 Reading headline show (Nirvana’s final UK performance) scheduled for release later this year, this is easily the better concert of the two. Though it may not contain any material from Nevermind, Kurt’s performance and passion is far more evident here than the shoddy Reading show. You have to hand it to Sub Pop, they know their audience is not simply going to buy a straight remaster of Bleach. By including the extra concert (and glossy inlay book, no doubt), they will ensure a sizeable chunk of Nirvana’s audience make a repeat purchase.
To anyone who already owns Bleach, and doesn’t necessarily want to have to buy this reissue, you can achieve the same (and better) results by simply turning up your amp the next time you listen to this important record.
Buy the album on Amazon | [itunes link="http://itunes.apple.com/WebObjects/MZStore.woa/wa/viewAlbum?id=336377945&s=143444&uo=4" title="Nirvana-Bleach_(20th_Anniversary_Deluxe_Edition)_(Album)" text="iTunes"]
Related posts
Other albums by this artist
really wanna hear this
You may find this Bleach Reissue debate among Nirvana Audiophiles interesting. -Brian
http://www.livenirvana.com/forum/showthread.php?t=34008
Well , the view of the passage is totally correct ,your details is really reasonable and you guy give us valuable informative post, I totally agree the standpoint of upstairs. I often surfing on this forum when I m free and I find there are so much good information we can learn in this forum!
Against-Myself
Heh. Let’s be frank.
For 2009 standards, this remastering work is AWESOME.
I can see no brick walled thing in your WL shots.
Though most of the “music” (or what has been left of it) is compressed so hard that you only get a block with some small tears (rhymes with bears, although you could also shed tears that rhyme with fears seeing this happen to music)
Proponujemy zapoznac sie z artykulami dotyczacymi tatuowania, dostepnymi na naszej stronie. Atmosfere popsul fakt, ze w któryms momencie przestano przyjmowac jakiekolwiek zamówienia co wywolalo duze zdenerwowanie gosci wcale im sie nie dziwie. I wtedy tez [url=http://www.nashvillenews.org/index.php/member/136996/]bieszczady noclegi domki letniskowe[/url] pojawi sie polska edycja albumu tria. Zapraszam do korzystania z wypoczynku [url=http://www.asianborderlands.net/cyripiotr]bieszczady noclegi nad solina[/url] w naszym domu przez caly rok. Winiary przylaczono do Gniezna z mysla potrzebach budownictwa [url=http://www.mycustomer.com/blogs/cyripiotr/bieszczady-noclegi]noclegi bieszczady tanio[/url] mieszkaniowego. Wiele atrakcji turystycznych w bezposrednim sasiedztwie pólwyspu [url=http://www.booktrix.com/live/index.php/member/41200/]noclegi bieszczady domki[/url] helskiego. Znajdziesz u nas restauracje rosyjskie z calej Polski. W kuchni wyprowadzone dodatkowe instalacje do pralki czy zmywarki. Do dyspozycji gosci mamy calkowicie umeblowana kuchnie w której szybko i sprawnie mozna przygotowac posilek [url=http://mytidewatermoms.com/users/cyripiotr]bieszczady noclegi ustrzyki gorne[/url] dla kilku osób oraz i trzyosobowe wygodne pokoje z zapierajacym dech w piersiach widokiem na Tatry, balkonem i TV. Przez caly sezon zuzlowcy Unibaksu spisywali [url=http://justcauseit.com/user/cyripiotr]bieszczady noclegi domki letniskowe[/url] sie fantastycznie, pewnie wygrywajac runde . Do dyspozycji wynajmujacych jest samodzielne dwupokojowe mieszkanie wraz z kuchnia i lazienka. Mozna bylo co robic z gdyby [url=http://michiganworks.org/member/23286/]bieszczady noclegi tanie[/url] snieg nie dopisal. Nie ma miast, w których nie bylyby dostepne dla wszystkich liczne myjnie samochodowe przede wszystkim na stacjach benzynowych choc nie tylko. [url=http://community.usatourist.com/members/cyripiotr.aspx]karkonosze noclegi tanio[/url] Dziela sie one ze wzgledu na ilosc osi jakie posiadaja, bez watpienia im wiecej tym lepiej. Autokar pozwala na wygodny dojazd a dojazd wlasny samochodem pozwala [url=http://www.mycustomer.com/blogs/cyripiotr/bieszczady-noclegi]noclegi bieszczady tanio[/url] na wycieczki na miejscu w zaleznosci od preferencji. Z samego serca wsi obserwuje budowe portu i oczami wyobrazni widzi przyszle [url=http://www.connectingindians.com/user.php?op=userinfo&uname=cyripiotr]bieszczady noclegi forum[/url] duze i nowoczesne portowe miasto. Organizator nie zapewnia ubezpieczenia uczestników od niebezpiecznych wypadków.
Milosnicy wedkowania beda mogli realizowac swoja pasje w pobliskiej rzeczce, a okoliczne lasy to swietne miejsce na udane grzybobranie. Mialaby to byc wielomiliardowa inwestycja, a hotel nie mialby sobie wnego w Polsce. Kraj ten byl najbardziej na wshud wysunietym panstewkiem niemieckim. Jest to swietne miejsce nie tylko na wyjazdy rodzinne, ale takze biznesowe, gdyz hotel posiada sale konferencyjne na miejsc, swietnie wyposazone w najnowszy sprzet. Latek zaatakowal funkcjonariuszy nozem szczul ich psem oraz podpalil mieszkanie w którym przebywal. Nie interesuja mnie takie imprezy, ale zdawalem sobie sprawe, ze byla duzym prestizem dla miasta. Takze w tym roku, prócz zaliczanego do klasyfikacji . Minutowy spacer lesna sciezka zaprowadzi nas nad morze. Wykup u nas ubezpieczenie Ochrona w przypadku szkód wyrzadzonym innym osobom. Na rozdrozy szlak zielony odbija w lewo do wsi Wadolno, a szlak niebieski w prawo do . Jak ile nie jesienia masz jedyna okazje na stoczenie bitwy na korona drzewa w pobliskim parku. Systemowa konstrukcja stalowa oparta jest na portalowych ramach polaczonych przegubowo z fundamentem. Rozwój ten byl tak wielki, ze wkrótce ani Jastarnia, ani Bór czy pobliska Kuznica nie byly w stanie mu sprostac. Wyprawa quadowa wedlug zyczenia Klienta moze konczyc sie ogniskiem lub grillem. Zarabia w Anglii lepiej niz przecietny Anglik, bo pracuje w swoim zawodzie, a jest dobrym inzynierem. Wprowadzono w katedrze wiele zmian podwyzszony zostal ambit, powstala istniejaca do dzis konfesja sw. We wszystkich z tych lokalizacji jest przedzial czasu gdzie mozna znalezc hotel krakow rezerwacja podczas pobytu w danym terenie.